U.S. Court of Appeals Decision: A Milestone for Scouting America's Survivors

Reflection on the U.S. Court of Appeals Decision

On May 13, 2025, a pivotal decision was reached by the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit concerning the ongoing support of survivors of historical abuse in Scouting America. The Court dismissed a series of appeals against the Bankruptcy Court's plan confirmation order, brought forward by a minority group of dissenting claimants and certain holdout insurance companies. This ruling is seen as a significant victory for the organization and, most importantly, for the estimated 20,000 survivors affected by past abuses.

Scouting America expressed strong approval of the Court’s decision, highlighting it as the result of extensive efforts from various stakeholders over the past five years. This collective commitment included surviving victims, local councils, chartered organizations, insurance companies, and others working tirelessly to ensure fair compensation while preserving the scouting mission.

The Court’s decision resolved multiple appeals, thus ensuring that the Settlement Trust established under the Scouting plan can continue its essential work. This trust, valued at approximately $2.4 billion, is designed to provide financial compensation to survivors, marking a critical step in the healing process for many individuals harmed in the past. To date, over $138 million has already been distributed, affirming the Trust's commitment to delivering justice to the victims.

In an official statement, Scouting America elaborated on the substantial impact of the ruling. It assured survivors that the Trust will carry on its mission without disruption, allowing them to focus on their recovery while the Trust continues to provide necessary financial compensation. The ruling not only signifies progress for those who have suffered but also indicates a more robust organizational framework moving forward.

Importantly, the decision also preserves Scouting America’s mission of fostering responsible citizenship among young people. The organization has endeavored to create a safe environment where youth can grow and learn valuable life skills guided by its foundational Scout Oath and Law. Shortly before the court ruling, Scouting America marked its 115th anniversary, during which it rebranded to reflect an inclusive approach, welcoming every youth and family across the nation.

Currently, the organization serves over a million youngsters, providing them with rich programs focused on character development and leadership training. Such initiatives ensure that young people are 'Prepared. For Life.®', equipping them with the tools they need to succeed in various social environments. The dismissal of the appeals, therefore, not only affirms the organization’s historical commitment to justice but also its future-oriented approach to youth development.

As this chapter unfolds, Scouting America remains committed to supporting survivors while simultaneously expanding its outreach programs. The organization encourages families to engage with their local councils and consider enrollment, continuing to deliver a legacy of growth and learning to the youth of America. The transition from crisis to recovery reinforces the vital role Scouting plays in the lives of young people, fostering community resilience and ensuring a safer environment for future generations.

For more information on how to be a part of Scouting America and support its mission, you can visit BeAScout.org.