Competing Organizations Reach Settlement Over Historic Tun Tavern Lawsuit in Philadelphia

Settlement Reached in the Historic Tun Tavern Lawsuit

In a significant development for Philadelphia’s rich historical landscape, two organizations have resolved their legal dispute concerning the recreation of the famed Tun Tavern. The settlement, announced on February 6, 2026, between Aljess LLC and The Tun Legacy Foundation, paves the way for the long-awaited restoration of this landmark that played a pivotal role in American history.

The Historical Significance of Tun Tavern

Originally built in 1686 on the Philadelphia waterfront, the Tun Tavern served as a bustling meeting point during the colonial era. It is notable as the place where key figures, including the framers of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution, gathered. Furthermore, the tavern was home to the first U.S. Marine Corps recruitment station and hosted the early meetings of the Free and Accepted Masons in North America. Such historical relevance highlights the importance of its restoration as a tribute to the nation’s founding narrative.

Despite its demolition in the late 18th century, the legacy of the Tun Tavern endured, inspiring numerous restoration attempts over the years. The latest initiative spearheaded by The Tun Legacy Foundation aims to create a historically accurate recreation a short distance from the tavern’s original location in Old City Philadelphia, contributing to the ongoing cultural narrative of the region.

The Controversial Lawsuit

Aljess LLC, under the ownership of former Marine Montgomery Dahm, has held the trademark rights to the Tun Tavern name since 1998, maintaining a brewpub under the same name in Atlantic City. Conflict arose when The Tun Legacy Foundation announced plans to build its own replica in November 2023, drawing Aljess into a legal battle over trademark infringement claims. Aljess argued that this new venture would potentially confuse customers about the two establishments.
In November 2025, following the ongoing lawsuit that began in May 2024, Aljess opened another restaurant under the Tun Tavern name on Chestnut Street in Old City, amplifying the competitive atmosphere surrounding the historic name.

Resolution of the Dispute

The dispute reached a resolution between the organizations, allowing the Legacy Foundation to proceed with its project utilizing the Tun Tavern name. Specific financial details of the settlement remain confidential; however, the dismissal of the lawsuit is public knowledge. This settlement not only secures the platform for the foundation to advance its construction plans but also allows Aljess to maintain the right to open new Tun Tavern locations elsewhere in the United States.
Dahm expressed satisfaction over the matter, emphasizing that for him, the history surrounding Tun Tavern surpasses mere business interests. He stated, “As a Marine, the history of the Tun Tavern is a matter of honor and heritage… I am confident that The Tun Legacy Foundation will successfully accomplish that goal.” His sentiment underlines the deep-rooted connection both parties have to the history of the Tun Tavern.

Craig Mills, representing The Tun Legacy Foundation, praised the team that supported the organization through the legal process, stating pride in being involved in such a significant project that aims to bring back to the city a key component of its history. With around $11 million raised for the aimed $21 million construction budget, the foundation continues to pursue resourcing for the full restoration.

The Impact of The Tun’s Restoration

The restored Tun Tavern is anticipated to serve not just as a restaurant but also as a memorial to the many organizations that have roots at the original site, notably the veteran groups and charitable societies that were founded there. This new establishment aims to be a vibrant part of Philadelphia’s cultural fabric, providing historical flow and honoring the city’s legacy.
The path forward for the Tun Tavern reflects a commitment to preserving historical integrity while allowing for modern expressions of that heritage, a crucial balance in today’s development landscape. As the city considers further development, the story of the Tun Tavern will be retold, enriching Philadelphia’s history for future generations.

The emergence of cooperation between Aljess and The Tun Legacy Foundation symbolizes progress, signaling that partnership and respect for history can lead to a celebrated resolution in complex situations.