#United States #Washington #White House History #White House Quarterly #Pierre L'Enfant

Exploring the 'White House That Wasn't'

The White House Historical Association has just unveiled an intriguing new edition of the White House History Quarterly. Titled "The White House That Wasn’t," this issue paints a vivid picture of the many scenarios, events, and ideas related to the White House that could have been, but ultimately did not come to fruition. The quarterly has long been a rich resource for those looking to understand the nuances and intricacies of one of the most famous buildings in the world, and this edition takes a creative twist on that narrative.

A Look Back in Time

The exploration begins way back in 1791, a time when the Federal City was still a mere concept existing only on paper. At this stage, city planner Pierre Charles L’Enfant crafted an ambitious vision for what the capital could be, including a presidential residence that, if constructed to his original specifications, would have been exponentially larger than the iconic structure we know today. The dauntingly grand design was planned to be at least five times the actual size constructed by architect James Hoban.

Artistic interpretations of L’Enfant's dream are showcased throughout the issue, including a stunning panorama painted by contemporary artist Peter Waddell. Waddell engages the reader through discussions about his work, titled "The Indispensable Plan," which visualizes what the President's House may have looked like. His paintings prompt readers to ponder not just the architectural possibilities, but also how a vastly different White House might have influenced the American experience.

The Colors of the White House

In keeping with the theme, architectural historian Kyle Dugdale contributes an insightful piece discussing the colors of the White House. Contrary to its well-known white exterior, he reveals that the stone used for the structure possesses a vibrant palette, ranging from pale tan to darker rusty shades, streaked with hues of buff, yellow, and red. This acknowledgment highlights that the White House is not just a singularly white entity, but a nuanced architectural marvel that carries layers of history and aesthetic complexity.

The Germantown Refuge

Furthermore, the issue also takes a historical leap to explore lesser-known presidential sites. Professor Alan Capps leads readers to a temporary residence used by George Washington in Germantown, Pennsylvania, during the yellow fever epidemic of 1793. The Germantown White House serves as a reminder that the history of presidential accommodations extends beyond the iconic 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue address, illustrating that various places played pivotal roles in the personal and political lives of the nation’s leaders.

International Connection

Adding depth to the narrative, author Sarah M. G. Mackay discusses an unusual yet fascinating aspect of presidential history: Scotland’s Culzean Castle. This charming castle was gifted to General Dwight D. Eisenhower, recognizing his contributions as Allied Commander during World War II. Revered as “Scotland’s White House,” this locale provided a serene retreat for Eisenhower that added an international dimension to American presidential history.

Objects That Never Made It

Another notable article focuses on the numerous objects that were intended for the White House but subsequently rejected. William G. Allman, the former White House Curator, shares captivating anecdotes, such as Steinway's offer of its no. 500,000 custom-designed grand piano, which the White House ultimately declined. Such stories provide a glimpse into the meticulous selection process behind the various artifacts housed within the residence.

A Historical Christmas

Professor John Hutton brings to light the lesser-known narrative surrounding the Christmas traditions in the White House, specifically examining the first potential Christmas tree. He highlights a story that suggests there may have been earlier celebrations than previously documented, thus rebuffing the common narrative that is widely accepted today.

Myth Busting and Unseen Legacies

In a delightful take on tradition, Katie Hatton dissects the myth surrounding Martin Van Buren allegedly receiving tiger cubs as gifts, digging into the authenticity of historical tales that have circulated about past presidents. Additionally, Frederic J. Frommer provides insight into an overlooked aspect of American governance—the absence of a vice president for extended periods, prompting reflection on how such gaps in leadership might have influenced federal decision-making.

Closing Reflections

The issue concludes with an evocative piece by Stewart D. McLaurin, reflecting on Jacqueline Kennedy’s vision of a restored White House, encapsulating both the aspirations tied to presidential heritage and the remaining unfinished business that is part of its story.

Valued at $12.95, the publication presents readers with a rich, thought-provoking examination of alternate histories and the many facets of the Presidential Mansion. To obtain a copy or subscribe to future editions, enthusiasts can visit White House History Journal's website. Through its releases, the White House Historical Association continues to inspire a deeper engagement with American history and the rich legacy associated with its leaders and their homes.