Family of Deceased Army Soldier Sues for Accountability in Cover-Up Following Tragic Death

Family of Deceased Army Soldier Sues for Accountability

On April 22, 2025, the grieving parents of Private First-Class Noah Samuel-Siegel filed two significant federal lawsuits against the U.S. Army. Noah, a 19-year-old soldier, tragically died by suicide while stationed at Camp Humphreys in South Korea in November 2021. The lawsuits, one invoking the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) and the other under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), allege that the Army concealed vital information and delayed necessary actions following their son's death.

The complaints state that the Army failed to respond adequately to Noah's serious mental health decline, misleading his family during a time of profound grief. Specific allegations mention how Noah faced harassment and intimidation after he expressed concerns about mandatory COVID-19 vaccinations. According to the family’s legal representatives, the Army mismanaged internal investigations and provided conflicting findings, worsening the family's emotional burden as they sought answers.

Margaret and Yehonatan Samuel-Siegel, Noah's parents, assert that the Army's neglect significantly contributed to their son’s distress and eventual death. Details from the complaints reveal that Noah exhibited behaviors commonly associated with suicidal ideation but received inadequate support from his superiors. This lack of intervention starkly contrasts with the Army’s stated commitment to mental health care and wellness for its personnel.

In the FTCA lawsuit filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey, the Samuel-Siegel family accuses the Army of failing to follow up on established protocols to monitor Noah’s mental health. In response to his visible struggles—including issues like insomnia and social withdrawal—the Army is alleged to have refrained from taking proactive measures to ensure Noah's well-being.

The APA lawsuit aims to force the Defense Health Agency (DHA) to act on the family's medical malpractice claim stemming from the Army's negligence. This claim initially filed under the Military Claims Act arose after medical staff reportedly ignored clear warning signs of Noah’s mental distress. After Noah's sad passing, his family has been in a prolonged state of uncertainty, having filed an appeal that has remained unresolved for more than six months.

Margaret and Yehonatan released a statement emphasizing their belief that the militaristic culture led to their son's untimely demise. They expressed, "Noah enlisted to serve his country—not to be bullied to death. The Army’s toxic leadership put Noah at risk. The Army then ignored protocols that could have saved him. They failed Noah, and us, at every turn."

In addition to seeking justice regarding their son's death, the lawsuits advocate for sweeping changes in how the military addresses issues related to mental health and the treatment of personnel who exhibit mental distress. Carol Thompson, the attorney representing the Samuel-Siegel family, stated that these legal actions transcend accountability for Noah’s suicide; they emphasize the necessity of reform in how the Army communicates with grieving families and handles sensitive mental health issues.

The Federal Practice Group, which represents the Samuel-Siegels, is known for its commitment to advocacy in cases involving federal employees and military personnel. The firm highlights the importance of ensuring accountability, transparency, and reform at the highest levels of government to prevent future tragedies.

In conclusion, this tragic case underscores the urgent need for systemic changes in military culture and policies. The Samuel-Siegel family's battle is not just for justice for Noah; it signifies a call to action for enhanced mental health awareness and a commitment to supporting the men and women who serve our country.

About Federal Practice Group

Federal Practice Group is a Washington, D.C.-based law firm specializing in representing federal employees, military personnel, and individuals affected by government misconduct. With vast expertise in FTCA claims, military justice, and constitutional rights, the firm strives for justice and accountability in every case it handles.