#Canada #Toronto #McLean & Company #Quality of Hire #HR Metrics

Closing the Hiring Gap

In the current competitive landscape, organizations are acutely aware of the importance of effective hiring practices. Global HR research and advisory firm McLean & Company has recently published a pivotal resource, the "Guide to Measuring Quality of Hire," designed at a time when HR leaders are facing increasing demands to optimize their hiring investments while showing the tangible benefits of their talent selection strategies.

Despite substantial investments in recruitment and onboarding, many organizations find themselves lacking the necessary metrics to assess whether these hires lead to meaningful, long-term impacts. The latest guide tackles this challenge head-on, providing a practical framework that empowers HR teams to measure the quality of hires confidently. By doing so, they can enhance employee retention, boost productivity, and turn hiring into a strategic contributor to overall business performance.

Understanding the Hiring Process

According to data published in LinkedIn's "2025 Global Recruiting Trends," a staggering 89% of talent acquisition professionals agree that measuring the quality of hire is critical for improving recruiting effectiveness. Yet, only 25% express confidence in their ability to measure it accurately. This disparity has significant financial repercussions: companies in the U.S. typically spend about 20% of an entry-level salary and over 200% of an executive's salary to replace a departing employee. Additionally, it often takes new hires three to eight months to reach a level of productivity expected of them.

To tackle these challenges, McLean & Company advises organizations to clearly define success criteria, establish key metrics like performance, time to productivity, and retention rates, and include both HR and business leaders in the evaluation process. By doing so, hiring can be transformed into a strategic initiative that enhances engagement, aligns with workplace culture, and promotes sustainable business outcomes.

Elysca Fernandes, the director of HR Research Advisory Services at McLean & Company, emphasizes, "Quality of hire is an essential HR metric because it captures the true return on an organization's investments in talent. It necessitates moving beyond mere intuition and isolated reviews to a structured, evidence-based methodology that involves both HR professionals and business managers."

The Two-Part Framework

The guide presents a two-part framework aimed at operationalizing the measurement of quality of hire:

1. Preparing to Measure

- Define the Scope: Clearly articulate what success in hiring looks like for your organization.
- Establish Success Criteria: Determine the key performance indicators that will be used post-hire, such as retention and performance metrics.
- Optional Quality of Hire Surveys: Develop additional tools to gauge new hire performance over time.

2. Measuring and Improving

- Create Scorecards: Establish a scorecard system to track performance.
- Analyze Results: Delve into the data to identify both strengths and pain points in hiring processes.
- Communicate Insights: Use storytelling techniques to convey findings, making the case for actionable changes.
- Action Planning: The insights gained from measurement should inform targeted plans for improving hiring, onboarding, and overall personnel development.

Key Insights from the Research

The research highlights several critical insights:

• - Shared Accountability: Measurement of quality of hire cannot occur in a vacuum. Collaboration with business leaders is essential to ensure the results prompt significant change.
• - Complexity of Quality of Hire: Quality of hire should not be reduced to a single number. A deeper analysis is essential to uncover the core reasons behind performance variances and the potential for scaling successful practices.
• - Closing the Loop: Initial measurement is just one step; the practical value emerges when organizations utilize these insights to refine their hiring strategies, enhance onboarding procedures, and increase new employee retention rates.

Practical Guidance and Resources

Additionally, the "Guide to Measuring Quality of Hire" equips HR executives with clear guidance on defining quality of hire tailored specifically for their organizations. It includes sample survey questions, scorecards, and adaptable measurement strategies ensuring ongoing alignment with organizational objectives as circumstances change.

By implementing this approach, organizations can move from a reactive talent acquisition model to a proactive and strategic function, effectively maximizing the impact of every hiring decision. This shift ultimately leads to enhanced engagement, improved retention rates, and better alignment with company culture, culminating in elevated performance on a broader business scale.

For those interested in media inquiries, or for expert insights on human resources and crisis management strategies, they can reach out to McLean & Company's Communications Manager, Katie Tame, at [email protected].

To utilize workshops and advisory services aimed at creating a measurable talent acquisition strategy, visit McLean & Company's Talent Acquisition Strategy Workshop.

In a world where talent distinguishes the best organizations from the rest, understanding and measuring the quality of hires is not just beneficial but essential. As businesses navigate their future, adopting structured methods to evaluate and improve hiring processes will position them ahead of the curve, ensuring they not only hire the right employees but also create environments where those employees can thrive.