ASPCA Applauds NYC Council for Landmark Legislation to End Horse-Drawn Carriages

On October 22, 2026, the ASPCA® (The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals®) expressed their support for the New York City Council's recent decision to pass Romanch's Law, previously known as Ryder's Law. This progressive measure aims to phase out horse-drawn carriage operations in the bustling streets of New York City by June 1, 2028.

The passing of this bill is a significant step towards improving animal welfare, as it establishes a responsible transition period of two years. This timeframe is essential for ensuring the humane retirement and placement of carriage horses, alongside a dedicated workforce transition program for the drivers and stable workers involved in the industry. The ASPCA has long been at the forefront of advocating for better treatment of animals and aims to alleviate the strains faced by horses forced to navigate busy city streets.

Matt Bershadker, the President and CEO of the ASPCA, voiced concerns about the inherent risks associated with horse-drawn carriages. He remarked, “Forcing horses to pull carriages through New York City’s busy, loud streets is unsafe and places an undeniable strain on their quality of life.” The decision follows decades of debate and a history filled with incremental reforms and tragic incidents that have underscored public concern surrounding this practice, notably after the untimely death of Romanch Mahajan.

Animal welfare organizations have continually raised their voices against the use of horse-drawn carriages, highlighting the growing support for phasing out this industry. Various stakeholders, including the Central Park Conservancy, elected officials, and public safety advocates, have come together, recognizing the need for a modern approach that respects both animal welfare and public safety.

In expressing gratitude to Council Member Marte and Speaker Menin for their leadership, Bershadker further urged Mayor Mamdani to sign Intro. 943 into law. “This historic legislation will phase out horse-drawn carriages while paving a responsible path forward for both the horses and the workers who depend on this industry,