Replay Sports Cards Makes Its Mark in New York
Replay Sports Cards, recognized as America's pioneering national franchise focused solely on the sports card hobby, proudly announces the opening of its very first New York location. This new shop opens its doors on
November 21, 2026 in Bellmore, a vibrant community on Long Island, conveniently situated at
2156 Bellmore Ave, Bellmore, NY 11710. The store is owned by
Rob Ansalone, a local resident whose passion for sports and card collecting laid the foundation for this new venture.
Bringing Community Together
The establishment of this shop not only marks a significant expansion of Replay Sports Cards into one of the nation's most enthusiastic sports markets, but it also symbolizes a heartfelt return to Ansalone's roots. Growing up in the same neighborhood as Replay's co-founder
Mike Martin, Ansalone's connection to the local community was a pivotal factor in this venture. "I wanted to create a welcoming environment where collectors can meet, trade, and enjoy their shared passion," Ansalone expressed, reflecting on the cherished relationships that the hobby can foster.
A Lifelong Journey
Before embarking on this entrepreneurial journey, Ansalone spent years working as an insurance broker and even owned a gym franchise. However, the thrill of reconnecting with his childhood sports card collection, particularly while sharing this experience with his son, reignited his love for the hobby. This led him to envision a shop where families can come together to enjoy card collecting, fostering a new generation of enthusiasts. "Getting back into cards with my son reminded me how special this hobby really is," he noted.
Personal Significance and Community Focus
For Ansalone and Martin, this shop is about more than just business; it captures a shared legacy. Martin shared, “Opening a Replay shop in my hometown is a true full-circle moment for me. I spent over 20 years in this community, and having this shop just a few minutes from my childhood home means so much.” Their story emphasizes Replay's commitment to creating spaces that reflect the community's energetic spirit.
Expanding the Card Collecting Experience
Replay Sports Cards aims to cultivate a sense of belonging within the trading card community by offering a wide array of services including buying, selling, trading, and grading cards. The company strikes a balance between the traditional in-store experience and modern digital engagement, featuring online sales, livestream commerce, and community events.
As Replay expands across the U.S., it aspires to partner with passionate entrepreneurs who share its vision of building strong community ties through the hobby of card collecting. Collectors interested in joining the growing network can explore opportunities by visiting
replaysportscards.com/franchise.
About Replay Sports Cards
Founded as the first-ever sports card shop franchise, Replay Sports Cards stands out for its dedication to creating a comprehensive experience for card collectors. The franchise prides itself on an approachable atmosphere that welcomes individuals of all ages and experience levels. With a notable presence at major card shows nationally and a growing number of locations, Replay blends modern retail strategies with a profound passion for the card-collecting community. For more information, visit
replaysportscards.com.
As Replay Sports Cards continues to connect fans, families, and collectors, the Bellmore location is set to become a central hub for sports enthusiasts on Long Island, reflecting the heart of the community it serves.