#Canada #Toronto #BCG #CivicAction

Unveiling the Hidden Costs of the Housing Crisis in the GTHA

A collaborative effort by the Boston Consulting Group (BCG) and CivicAction has shed light on the alarming effects of the housing crisis gripping the Greater Toronto and Hamilton Area (GTHA) and Canada at large. The recently published report titled Greater Toronto and Hamilton Area Housing Crisis Hidden Costs, Bold Solutions outlines substantial challenges that threaten not only the housing market but also the broader economic stability in the region.

The Economic Implications of Housing Unaffordability

According to the findings, the GTHA is not merely facing a housing dilemma but rather a full-scale economic crisis that affects productivity and labor. Kristin Wheatley, a Managing Director and Partner at BCG, stated, "This isn't just a housing issue—it's a full-blown economic, productivity, and labour crisis." Teachers, healthcare professionals, tradespeople, and other essential workers are being priced out of the area, inhibiting their ability to continue contributing to the region’s growth.

A staggering statistic shared in the report highlights that nearly 50% of households in the GTHA earn between $40,000 and $125,000 annually. This group, labeled the “Squeezed-Out Working Population,” struggles to find affordable housing that would allow them to remain in close proximity to their workplaces, creating a series of economic and social challenges.

The Ripple Effects of Housing Costs

The ramifications of the housing crisis extend beyond the immediate discomfort of unaffordable living conditions:

• - Economic Drag: High housing costs lead to reduced disposable income for families, which in turn slows down economic growth across the region.
• - Labour Shortages: Employers are having difficulty attracting and retaining talent, resulting in an estimated $2.8 billion increase in payroll expenses annually.
• - Straining Social Services: Rising food insecurity now affects employed individuals, as over 50% of new food bank clients in Toronto come from working households.
• - Healthcare Costs: Housing instability contributes to deteriorating health conditions, thereby increasing reliance on emergency services and healthcare systems.

These issues collectively paint a picture of a region struggling under the weight of housing unaffordability, which endangers the economic fabric of Canada.

Systemic Barriers Hindering Progress

The report lays out critical barriers that impede progress towards a more affordable housing landscape. These include restrictive zoning laws, protracted approval timelines, misaligned market incentives, and a shortage of construction labor. Leslie Woo, CEO of CivicAction, emphasized, "Housing unaffordability in the GTHA isn't new, but it has reached an alarming level that impacts Canada's economic stability."

The pressing need for aligned action among governments, businesses, and community leaders is more important now than ever. This collaboration is essential for developing efficient housing policies and financing strategies that promote sustainable living environments.

Global Insights: Learning from Other Cities

The report cites international examples of successful housing solutions that could be adopted in the GTHA:

• - Public Housing Expansion: Cities like Vienna and Singapore effectively offer government-supported housing for essential workers.
• - Faster, Smarter Construction: Countries such as Sweden and cities like Boston have adopted streamlined approval processes and prefabricated construction methods to increase housing supply.
• - Blended Finance Models: Public-private financing strategies in France and Denmark have been instrumental in funding affordable housing projects.
• - Integrated Urban Planning: Tokyo and Portland have made strides in combining zoning reforms with transit expansions to facilitate workforce housing.

A Collaborative Path Forward

The BCG and CivicAction report calls for immediate action to address these challenges, including fast-tracking approvals for workforce housing and modernizing zoning regulations. "The solutions exist—what's missing is coordinated action," asserts Nan DasGupta, a BCG Senior Advisor and CivicAction Board member.

By uniting efforts around proven methodologies and shared frameworks, stakeholders can work together to ensure the GTHA remains not only economically viable but also a welcoming home for its diverse population. As the GTHA stands at this crossroads, the urgency for cooperative solutions is paramount for preserving its future as an inclusive and thriving region.