#USA #Burlington #Young's Scale #Gemology #Vermont Gem Lab

The Breakthrough of Young's Durability Scale in Gemology

The gemology industry is witnessing a significant advancement with the introduction of Young's Durability Scale, an innovative framework designed to evaluate the durability of gemstones more comprehensively than ever before. This model, developed by Kennon Young from the Vermont Gemological Laboratory, addresses the limitations of the traditional Mohs hardness scale, which has been the benchmark for assessing gemstones for nearly 200 years. While the Mohs scale measures only hardness, Young's Durability Scale combines hardness, fracture toughness, and inclusions into a robust framework.

Rethinking Durability

Historically, jewelers, gemologists, and consumers have relied heavily on the Mohs scale, created in 1812 by Friedrich Mohs. However, Mohs himself indicated that hardness is not the sole determinant of a mineral's durability. Hardness must not be mistaken for the ability to withstand impact or wear; many hard minerals can be fragile, while softer ones might boast remarkable toughness.

Young's Durability Scale builds upon this understanding, introducing a probabilistic model that evaluates gemstone durability through a blend of three critical factors:

• - Hardness (35% importance) – based on the Mohs scale, measures resistance to surface scratching.
• - Fracture Toughness (45% importance) – assesses resistances to chipping and cracking, making it the most crucial factor for practical usage.
• - Inclusions (20% importance) – evaluates how internal features of a gemstone can affect its overall strength.

This innovative combination leads to a comprehensive durability ranking, providing a much clearer understanding of how gemstones perform in real-life scenarios.

Surprising Rankings

The results yielded by Young's Durability Scale have proven both fascinating and unexpected. For instance, nephrite jade is ranked at the top of the scale due to its exceptional toughness and fibrous structure, achieving a durability score that surpasses even that of diamond. This highlights the historical use of jade in tools and ceremonial objects requiring both strength and aesthetic appeal. Conversely, although diamonds are known for their hardness, they receive a lower durability rating because they can cleave easily and are affected by specific inclusions. This explains the tendency of diamonds to chip if struck at an improper angle.

Conversely, stones like opal and fluorite rank poorly on the scale, reflecting their known fragility under normal wear.

These scores offer valuable insights for jewelers and consumers, aiding in predicting long-term wear and informing decisions when choosing gemstones for various types of jewelry.

Practical Implications

The introduction of Young's Durability Scale has brought significant implications across the gemology landscape. Jewelry designers can utilize the scale to select materials that combine beauty with practical durability, ensuring that their pieces last over time. For collectors and auction houses, the scale provides a reliable standard for assessing the risk and value of rare gemstones.

Insurance companies can enhance their risk assessment processes, while consumers can make better-informed decisions on their purchases, ensuring that they understand the care requirements for their chosen gemstones.

Retailers will find this scale particularly beneficial as a sales tool. By incorporating Young's Durability Scale into their sales training, they can enhance consumer confidence and build greater trust in their expertise and product offerings.

Kennon Young emphasizes this model's importance, stating, "This model finally gives the jewelry industry a practical, science-backed way to evaluate gemstone durability that goes far beyond scratch resistance."

A Cornerstone for the Future

Young's Durability Scale was recognized as a significant contribution to the field of gemology, having been vetted by experts at the Gemological Institute of America (GIA). However, it does not encompass every gemstone, as some lack sufficient data. For example, tourmaline has yet to be tested for fracture toughness. This model focuses on the statistically likely performance of gemstone species under typical usage conditions, offering jewelers, gemologists, and retailers a practical, research-based framework.

As consumer demand for transparency in gemology, ethical sourcing, and scientific rigor increases, the launch of this scale comes at an essential juncture for the industry. It offers the clarity needed to support innovation and ensure the durability of exquisite jewelry. This framework sets a new standard for how durability is evaluated within the trade, helping to bridge the gap between laboratory insights and everyday jewelry wear.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, Young's Durability Scale represents a pivotal moment in gemology, allowing for a more nuanced understanding of gemstone performance. It equips everyone from bench jewelers to consumers with the knowledge necessary to make informed decisions about gemstone usage and maintenance. As the jewelry industry continues to evolve, this scale may very well define the future of how gemstones are assessed for durability and longevity.