Replay Sports Cards Announces First Franchise Opening in New York Before Fanatics Fest 2026

Replay Sports Cards Expands to New York

Replay Sports Cards, the pioneering national franchise specializing in sports cards, is thrilled to announce its first franchise agreement in New York with local entrepreneur Rob Ansalone. This agreement marks a significant milestone as the company makes its much-anticipated debut in the Bellmore/Merrick region of Long Island. The new shop is set to launch in the fall of 2026, just in time for the upcoming Fanatics Fest taking place from July 16-19 in New York City.

Bringing Community-Centered Card Shop Experience

The forthcoming store will provide Long Island sports fans and collectors with a comprehensive card shopping experience. Designed as a full-service environment, it will encompass buying, selling, trading, and grading cards, all delivered in a welcoming community-driven atmosphere. Rob Ansalone, who hails from Merrick, has always had a passion for sports and collectibles but saw this venture as an opportunity to share that enthusiasm with his community after rekindling his love for the hobby by sharing it with his son.

"Getting involved in cards with my son helped me appreciate the special connections that this hobby fosters, and I'm eager to create a similar experience for others on Long Island," Ansalone expressed. Drawn to Replay because of its supportive franchise structure, Ansalone felt an instant connection with Replay co-founder Mike Martin, who shares a similar background. This personal rapport has given Ansalone the confidence to move forward with the new franchise.

Martin agrees, stating, "Long Island boasts a rich sports culture and community spirit, qualities that Rob embodies perfectly. His understanding of our concept will ensure that Replay's Bellmore location becomes a hotspot for local enthusiasts.”

Participation at Fanatics Fest 2026

As the franchise gears up for its new location, the Replay team is also excited to participate in Fanatics Fest 2026. The co-founders and Ansalone will be engaging with fans and collectors at this significant event, showcasing the brand’s commitment to building community relationships and growing the trading card hobby. Replay's presence will feature a dedicated retail space within the Fanatics Collect Card Combine, making the event accessible to a broader audience, especially families and kids who's interests lie within the world of trading cards.

Visitors can expect an inviting environment, where they’ll find affordable trading cards and receive guidance on pricing, grading, and valuation. This hands-on experience is crafted to demystify the world of card collecting for newcomers, making it a less intimidating activity.

"Our goal is to create an approachable and educational space for everyone," said Ansalone, adding that he hopes to make the hobby enjoyable for all ages. The franchise's participation in Fanatics Fest goes beyond immediate sales; it represents a vital step in their broader mission to make card collecting inclusive and accessible.

Giving Back to the Community

In keeping with its community-driven ethos, Replay Sports Cards has launched the Replay Gives Back initiative, successfully collecting over three million donated trading cards. These cards are repackaged and shared with children across the nation, further tying the franchise’s growth with its commitment to positively impact communities.

With five franchises in operation across the U.S. and a robust presence at major card shows, Replay Sports Cards combines a deep love for the hobby with modern retail practices, ensuring a delightful experience for collectors of all backgrounds.

As the new store is readied for its fall grand opening, anticipation builds among Long Island's sports enthusiasts. For those interested in exploring franchise opportunities with Replay, more information can be found at replaysportscards.com/franchise.

About Replay Sports Cards

Founded as One Stop Sports, Replay Sports Cards has emerged as the first-ever sports card shop franchise in the U.S. The brand is dedicated to creating accessible and exciting environments for card collectors of all ages. Through innovative retail practices and engaging community efforts, Replay aims to foster relationships within the hobby and adapt to the evolving landscape of sports collectibles.