#United States #Chicago #SEC #Brattle Group #PCAOB

Leadership Transitions and Policy Changes in Auditor Oversight

In a pivotal report released by The Brattle Group, it has been revealed that the third quarter of 2025 has brought significant changes to auditor oversight in the United States. The findings indicate that recent leadership shifts and policy updates are reshaping the landscape of auditor enforcement.

According to the report titled Enforcement Activity Involving Auditors – 2025 Q3 Update, authored by Principal Alison Forman and Associate Adam Karageorge, the period between January and September 2025 was marked by considerable transitions within the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) and the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The report reflects how these changes may influence enforcement activities going forward.

Key Findings from the Report

The report identifies that the first three quarters of 2025 were characterized by a noteworthy transition period for auditor enforcement. As highlighted by Ms. Forman, the swearing-in of SEC Chair Paul Atkins in April signaled a departure from the aggressive enforcement tactics seen in previous administrations. During Q3, enforcement activity significantly slowed, hinting at a realignment of priorities adopted by the new administration.

Notably, in the nine-month timeframe, the SEC only initiated one enforcement action against auditors, which occurred before the resignation of former SEC Chair Gary Gensler on January 20, 2025. In contrast, the PCAOB maintained a level of activity similar to past years, initiating 32 enforcement actions, though most occurred prior to Chair Erica Williams's departure in July.

Recent Developments Affecting Oversight

Several significant developments were flagged in the report:

• - New Leadership in Enforcement: Judge Margaret Ryan's unconventional appointment as Director of the SEC's Division of Enforcement showcases a fresh approach to the Commission's enforcement strategies.
• - Cross-Border Task Force Initiation: The establishment of a Cross-Border Task Force reflects the SEC's renewed focus on foreign companies potentially breaching US securities regulations, emphasizing scrutiny on gatekeepers like auditors and underwriters.
• - Presidential Budget Implications: Despite earlier discussions about its elimination, the PCAOB has been retained in President Trump's 2025 budget, following the dismissal of a provision advocating for its dissolution.
• - Executive Changes: PCAOB Chair Erica Williams resigned upon the request of SEC Chair Atkins, leading to calls for candidates to fill all five board positions, marking a complete overhaul in PCAOB leadership.
• - Adjustment of Quality Control Standards: The PCAOB delayed the implementation of its new quality control standard designed to enhance audit quality, shifting its effective date from December 15, 2025, to December 15, 2026.

Implications for Future Enforcement

The collective effect of these changes foreshadows a period of adjustment in auditor enforcement strategies, as highlighted by the report's authors. The slower pace of enforcement activity during Q3 might indicate a longer-term shift in focus, potentially aligning with the administration's evolving regulatory objectives.

For a comprehensive understanding of these shifts and their future implications on auditor operations, refer to the full report available on Brattle's official website. As the auditing landscape adapts to these pivotal changes, companies, investors, and stakeholders must stay informed to comprehend how these updates might affect their compliance and operational strategies moving into 2026 and beyond.

About The Brattle Group

The Brattle Group, renowned for its expertise in addressing complex economic, finance, and regulatory challenges, provides insights to corporations, law firms, and governments globally. With a team of over 500 skilled professionals across various regions, Brattle is known for the credibility of its insights, supported by leading academics and industry specialists.