#USA #Washington, D.C. #NAIC #Pension Funds #Diverse Investment

A Deep Dive into Diversity Challenges in Pension Fund Investments

The National Association of Investment Companies (NAIC) has recently unveiled a groundbreaking study uncovering the substantial barriers diverse-managed funds encounter in securing investments from pension funds. This comprehensive analysis, which spans the years from 2012 to 2022, highlights systemic inequities that not only stifle innovation and growth but also impact the overall financial performance of pension funds. Despite the proven benefits of diversity—such as more robust decision-making and superior returns—an alarming statistic shows that over 95% of investment capital is funneled into non-diverse fund management.

Key Findings from the Study

The NAIC's research brings to light several critical findings:

• - Underrepresentation: The overwhelming dominance of non-diverse funds remains evident, with 95% of capital commitments concentrated in these traditional portfolios, showcasing a deeply rooted disparity across various asset classes.
• - Investment Size Discrepancies: On average, diverse-managed funds claim investments that are approximately 25.6% smaller than their non-diverse counterparts, with funds headed by ethnically diverse women facing a staggering 37.8% reduction.
• - Disparities in Fund Sizes: To attract public pension investments, diverse-managed funds are expected to maintain a median Assets Under Management (AUM) of $45 billion, compared to just $20.2 billion for non-diverse funds, indicating a 123% higher benchmark that puts diverse funds at a disadvantage.
• - Varying Institutional Allocation Trends: Over the decade, public pension funds have incrementally increased allocations to diverse-managed funds, rising from 7.6% in 2012 to 11.1% in 2022. However, corporate pension commitments peaked at 7.9% in 2020 and have drastically decreased to just 4.3% in 2022. Union pension funds have also shown instability, reaching a peak of 9.8% before plunging back to 0% in the latest year.

The Role of Public Pension Funds

Public pension funds have consistently demonstrated a commitment to diverse-managed funds largely due to increased public accountability and the engagement of diverse stakeholders. The governance structures and decision-making approaches unique to these funds enable them to uphold specific social impact mandates. This is contrasted with corporate and union pension funds, which might enhance their diverse investment initiatives by learning from the successes and strategies of public pension funds.

Impacts on Market and Innovation

The disparities identified in the report pose significant challenges not only for potential investors but also for high-performing diverse talent within the financial sector. These barriers can thwart both innovation and market evolution. Robert L. Greene, the President and CEO of NAIC, mentioned, "We hope that details exposed by this study motivate corporate and union pensions to expand their capital flow towards this high-performing market segment."

Pioneers in Diverse Investments

The NAIC's study identifies the pension funds that made the most substantial commitments to diverse-led managers throughout the decade. Notably, the New York State Common Retirement Fund led public pensions with 62 commitments, while Duke University's Employees' Retirement Plan stood out in corporate pensions with 35 commitments. The Operating Engineers Trust Fund of Washington, D.C. led the union pensions with 21 commitments.

Conclusion

The research concludes that understanding the dynamics which drive fund investments can help encourage further diversity across all types of pension funds. The findings highlight the necessity for both awareness and action to dismantle these systemic barriers, paving the way for an equitable investment landscape that recognizes the essential contributions of diverse-managed funds. To read the full report, visit naicpe.com.

About NAIC

The National Association of Investment Companies, celebrating over 53 years of advocacy and performance, is the primary network of diverse- and women-owned alternative investment firms, with a membership exceeding 190 firms which collectively manage over $460 billion in assets.