#United States #Washington #trucking #Litigation #ATRI

New Insights Into Trucking Litigation

The American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI) has recently published groundbreaking research that sheds light on the expanding domain of tort litigation within the trucking sector. This comprehensive analysis covers critical factors influencing case outcomes and reveals startling statistics that paint a vivid picture of the challenges faced by the industry.

Scope of the Study

In a detailed examination that utilizes a diverse range of federal and industry litigation data, the report provides insights into six years of trucking tort cases. According to the data, 2022 alone witnessed a staggering 12,817 state truck-tractor tort cases. Alarmingly, it was found that as many as 147 cases were inappropriately barred from federal court—where claims generally receive enhanced protection from biases.

Rising Awards and Factors Influencing Outcomes

The report identifies a concerning trend: the largest half of the awards, which can be significantly damaging to trucking companies, increased at an average rate of 5.7% per year. Key factors were highlighted that statistically correlate with higher compensation, such as types of negligence, including improper hiring practices or onboarding processes. Notably, the severity of injuries like moderate to severe traumatic brain injuries also influenced the awards significantly.

A striking differentiation emerged in awards between settlements and verdicts. In cases where awards totaled $5 million or more, settlements were typically lower than verdicts. Conversely, for judgments under $1 million, settlements surpassed the verdict amounts.

Defense Challenges

The report further analyzes common trial strategies and found that employing counterclaims, which involve presenting evidence of plaintiff negligence, did not result in reduced awards for defendants. This indicates the substantial jury biases that motor carriers frequently face. In nearly 17.8% of cases, non-medical awards were shown to be more than 10 times higher than their medical counterparts, suggesting a tendency towards exaggerating non-medical claims.

Industry Reactions

The findings have evoked critical responses within the industry. Nathan J. Meisgeier, the President and Chief Legal Officer of Werner Enterprises, articulated the grave challenges posed by both frivolous and excessive litigation, emphasizing that such issues consume valuable resources and detract from improving operational efficiencies and safety measures.

Renee Amar, Executive Director of the Louisiana Motor Transport Association, echoed these sentiments, highlighting the report as a crucial reminder for policymakers to address the urgent need for a fair and balanced legal framework.

Conclusion

ATRI's research underscores the necessity for reforms within the legal system and the importance of a vigilant approach to navigating the complex and often challenging legal environment surrounding trucking litigation. Full insights from this crucial report are available on the ATRI's website, and they serve as a pivotal resource for industry stakeholders looking to understand and adapt to the evolving litigation landscape.

As the trucking industry continues to address these challenges, a concerted effort towards legal reform and strategic management will be essential for safeguarding the operational integrity and financial viability of trucking companies across the nation.