Examining the Clear Digital Divide in Insurance Preferences Across Generations
Recent findings from Sure illuminate a significant shift in consumer preferences with respect to insurance purchases, indicating a stark digital divide between younger and older consumers. According to their 2025 Consumer Sentiment Report, a significant 64% of Digital Natives—individuals born post-1975—believe that insurance should primarily be bought and managed online. With this generation potentially overshadowing older cohorts in terms of market size in the coming years, such preferences could drive substantial changes across the insurance sector.
The traditional insurance model, which often demands human interaction for transactions, is being challenged as young consumers express a compelling desire for digital solutions. In fact, 70% of these younger consumers have already experienced digital insurance transactions, marking a surge in digital capability's relevance within the sector. While many older consumers remain reliant on agents, the contrast in satisfaction levels is notable. Surprisingly, Digital Immigrants (those born in 1974 or earlier) who have ventured into digital insurance transactions report satisfaction levels akin to their younger counterparts, suggesting that the benefits of seamless, digital experiences transcend age groups.
Wayne Slavin, co-founder and CEO of Sure, stated, “Older consumers have been comfortable with the status quo, so the industry has remained stuck in the past as the rest of our purchasing experiences moved online.” The demand for change, however, is palpable—Digital Natives are keen on not just digital convenience but are also willing to switch providers to obtain it. This presents a prime opportunity for visionary companies within the insurance industry to take the lead in reshaping consumer experiences.
The importance of adapting to these digital preferences cannot be overstated. Historically, the insurance industry has experienced slow movement toward online capabilities, much like the early days of credit card adoption when cash and checks dominated transactions. Currently, insurance transactions still require a human touch at various points, which indicates a gap ripe for innovation.
Looking to the near future, embedded insurance—a model whereby insurance products are integrated directly into the services offered by various brands—could represent a transformative shift. Deloitte's projections foresee the global sales of embedded property and casualty insurance hitting $700 billion by 2030, indicating a lucrative evolution where traditional insurance methods may fall to the wayside.
According to Sure's research, 65% of consumers who have purchased insurance online did so via the brand they initially engaged with, further highlighting the potential benefits for brands that focus on embedding insurance solutions within their offerings. The data shows a considerable appetite for purchasing insurance from trusted brands, with two-thirds of respondents desiring more direct options from these brands.
The path forward for insurance providers can borrow lessons from other industries: just as airlines and retailers once offered co-branded credit cards to enhance customer loyalty, insurance brands too can carve out a niche by delivering tailored digital experiences. Sure is already paving this path with its existing network of carriers to facilitate insurance distribution through technological integration.
Ultimately, the trajectory towards a digital insurance future is clear. As younger consumers persist in voicing their preference for digital solutions and the capability for seamless transactions, the insurance industry stands at a crossroads. For those willing to adapt and embrace this shift, the rewards could redefine insurance as a consumer experience. The message is clear: to thrive, industry players must align with consumer demands and prepare to meet the digital future head-on, just like the sport of ice hockey requires skating to where the puck is going, not where it has been.
This pivotal moment necessitates a collective rethinking in how insurance is marketed, distributed, and ultimately experienced by all consumers. The Sure 2025 Consumer Sentiment Report serves as a wake-up call and an opportunity for the industry to redefine its strategies. By being proactive and responsive to these changing consumer preferences, we might see a flourishing era for digital insurance solutions.